top of page

Moments matter, problems persist

12 minutes ago
4 min read

A 2-0 defeat at struggling Colchester exposes familiar shortcomings


Originally published in Gills Journal by David Tickner




Gillingham paid the price of their recurring failure to defend set pieces as they were beaten 2-0 at Colchester United on Saturday. The hosts secured their first league win since August ending a ten-match winless sequence in League Two to lift them out of the relegation places.


Going into Saturday’s game, Colchester were, according to fotmob.com data, bottom of League Two for set-piece goals with just one scored previously in the current league season. But both of their second half goals, scored by Jack Payneand Harry Anderson, originated from set pieces and Gillingham’s failure to deal with them.

 

 

A new shape



Gareth Ainsworth made four changes to his starting eleven that had beaten an understrength Northampton Town in the EFL Trophy in midweek. Ethan Coleman and Harry Waldock came back into midfield alongside Zane Albarus whose managed return continued.



Sheldon Kendall started on the right with 39-year-old Garath McCleary, who had played all 90 minutes midweek, deployed on the left. Top scorer Ronan Hale was confined to the bench due to a groin injury. With Will Goodwin having suffered an injury setback and Tom Eaves not yet fully recovered from his own injury, Lamin Sillah, still playing with a bandaged wrist, was Gills’ closest to a fully fit striker.



Logan Dobbs returned to the centre of a defence that was missing Andy Smith, nursing an ankle injury. With Conor McManus absent on international duty, Nick Freeman and James Brophy dropped into full back positions as Ainsworth started with a back four for the first time this season.



It wasn’t a formation that clicked immediately as Gillingham struggled to assert midfield control and to feed Sillah up front.



As early as the fifth minute, there was a warning for Gillingham about defending corners when the unmarked Jay Williams met Payne’s delivery but headed over from close range. Teddy Bishop also went close, curling his left footed shot wide of the post as the hosts established the greater early threat.



As the half progressed, Gillingham gained more control in midfield creating opportunities for Kendall and McCleary without ever really threatening the Colchester goal. Just before the interval, a low shot from Anderson forced a good save from Ollie Wright and offered a reminder of the hosts’ threat.



Moments that changed the game



Gillingham’s best opportunity of the game fell to Harry Waldock early in the second half and might have changed the direction of the afternoon. Played in by Sillah, Waldock’s right foot shot on the angle from the edge of the box was tipped round the post by Colchester goalkeeper, Thimothee Lo-Tutala. Attacking towards the 1,255 away supporters who were now in good voice, the resultant corner was hit too long and went straight out of play. Gillingham’s attacking momentum was lost and was quickly taken up by the hosts.



Gillingham conceded an unnecessary free kick on their right-hand side. Payne’s delivery was headed behind by Dobbs for a corner. Gillingham failed to clear the danger decisively and became rooted on their six-yard line allowing Payne space to receive the ball in the penalty area. Brophy fouled him - the final consequence of a passage of poor defending rather than just an isolated individual error. Payne stepped up to convert the penalty with his left foot, sending Wright the wrong way.



Two minutes later, Payne had a good chance to double the lead, but Wright blocked the shot with his legs. There wasn’t long to wait for Colchester’s second goal. It followed another Colchester set piece from another unnecessarily conceded free kick. Gillingham failed to clear. Although there was an element of good fortune in the ball falling to Jack Tucker to play in Anderson who looked close to being offside, he finished from close range.



Poor defending and a hint of misfortune had allowed Colchester a two-goal lead, but it was also questionable as to whether Gillingham had done enough elsewhere in the game to justify expecting a better result.



Possession without purpose



Ainsworth acknowledged ‘We didn’t defend them (set pieces) well enough’ and admitted, ‘We’re going to have to maybe change what we do’. However, his wider post-match judgement was more charitable. ‘We never had major trouble at any time of the game,’ he said with Beckles adding, ‘We could take a lot of positives from it.’



Gillingham did enjoy nearly 62% of the game’s possession but it carried limited genuine goal threat and was often rolled sideways and slowly. Despite Gillingham’s 14 recorded goal attempts, only four were on target compared to Colchester’s seven from 13.

 


Injuries - context not excuses



Cameron Antwi, Hale, Armani Little and Smith were all waiting to come on as substitutes as Colchester’s second goal went in with 18 of the 90 minutes remaining. The Gills’ fans expressed their disappointment at the withdrawal of Albarus whom Ainsworth explained after the match was not permitted to complete 90 minutes because of concerns about managing the workload of the young player’s return. Of the current injuries and their impact on continuity, Beckles said after the game, ‘It’s not an excuse but it does disrupt your rhythm.’



It’s easy to criticise the substitutions and their timing but with each of these replacements returning from or carrying injuries, fitness restrictions had to be observed and acknowledged. ‘I cannot lose any more players,’ Ainsworth had said before the game.



Whilst injuries have undoubtedly weakened the options available to Ainsworth, organisation and decision-making in defensive situations have remained a problem and once again proved costly. Weaknesses in defending set pieces continue to be exploited even by opponents with an otherwise poor record, like Colchester. Ultimately though, Gillingham lost because they couldn’t impose themselves and take control of a game against one of the league’s bottom sides.



The manager will be grateful for no midweek game ahead of Saturday’s visit from fifth-placed Crewe Alexandra and an opportunity to get players back towards fitness. But the recurring problems defending set pieces are likely to require more than just another week on the training ground if Gillingham are to sustain a promotion challenge.



David Tickner writes regularly about Gillingham Football Club on Substack. You can read, follow or subscribe for free at Gills Journal | David Tickner | Substack.

Comments


AWAY TRAVEL BOOKINGS

Text Peter: 07930 443665

EMAIL US
SOCIAL MEDIA
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • X
bottom of page