top of page

The good, the bad and the mediocre

2 hours ago
5 min read

Ainsworth’s assessment of Gillingham’s 5-5-5 league season sets the scene ahead of the visit of fifth-placed Crewe


Originally published in Gills Journal by David Tickner


Crewe Alexandra will arrive at Priestfield sitting in the middle of the play-off places. With Gillingham now mid-table, the current standings suggest two teams experiencing different fortunes and a tough assignment for the Gills in Saturday’s lunchtime kick-off. However, just three points separate fifth-placed Crewe from the Gills in 12th.



And neither side is demonstrating convincing promotion form. Gareth Ainsworth’s side have won only once – at Shrewsbury – in their last five league matches. Crewe have gone four league games without winning. Their lofty league position disguises a draw-heavy record and recent defensive problems.



Both teams have won five of their opening 15 league games. Crewe’s eight draws compared with Gillingham’s five, account for the entire three-point difference between them. Both sides have conceded 12 goals in their previous six league games, suggesting they may be equally vulnerable defensively.



There is a symmetry to Gillingham’s current league record: five wins, five draws and five defeats. Speaking this week, Ainsworth accepted that record as a fair reflection of his side so far this season. He acknowledged that Gillingham haven’t won enough matches, have conceded avoidable goals and have alternated between performances that he described in the club’s media variously as ‘great’, ‘crap’ and ‘mediocre’. But the manager insists it tells only part of the story, pointing to the absence of around 30% of his squad through injury and remaining confident that the return of key players will transform his side’s prospects in the second half of the season.





Fortress Priestfield? Not lately



The Gills’ emphatic home victories over Tranmere and Bristol Rovers in September sunshine now seem distant memories. By Saturday, it will be nine weeks since Gillingham last won a home league game. Their seven home league games this season have produced just those two wins and a total of nine points. The recent FA Cup defeat by Barrow added to the sense that home advantage is being undermined and Priestfield far from yet being the fortress Ainsworth seeks.



Gillingham’s difficulties were evident again at Colchester last weekend, where they suffered a disappointing 2-0 defeat undone by poor defending at set pieces and an inability to create any sustained attacking threat. Injuries explain some of this, but ultimately, they were unable to impose themselves meaningfully on an opposition side who started the game in the relegation places following a ten-match winless sequence.



Ainsworth's message ahead of Crewe is to be ‘brilliant in both boxes’, rather than worrying too much about how attractive Gillingham might look in midfield. He also wants players to exercise better judgement over when to retain possession and when to move the ball forward quickly. For a side that enjoyed considerable possession at Colchester without making it count, the message seems pertinent.





The Railwaymen running out of steam?



Crewe’s away record is less imposing than their league position suggests. They have scored just five goals in seven away league games this season and lost their last two – 2-0 at Exeter and 5-1 at Chesterfield.



They went unbeaten in their first eleven games of this season although six of those games were drawn. Having been held to home draws by Barnet and Newport, they are now winless in four in the league.



Newport led 2-0 at half time at Gresty Road last weekend. After Lee Bell made three substitutions just before the hour, Charlie McNeill scored in the 77th minute and defender Josh Stephenson headed a 90th minute equaliser from a Matus Holicek cross.



Sheffield Wednesday loanee McNeill has scored three goals in his last four appearances, including an extraordinary goal from the halfway line in the FA Cup first round win over League One AFC Wimbledon. Jordan Gibson, signed from Doncaster Rovers last summer, leads the scoring with five goals and two assists in 15 league games.



Bell has been Crewe’s manager since December 2022. He guided the club to the 2024 League Two play-off final where they lost 2-0 to Scott Lindsey’s Crawley. They finished 13th in 2024/25 and 11th last season.





Reinforcements on the way



At Colchester last weekend, perhaps partly out of necessity, Ainsworth started with a back four using James Brophy and Nick Freeman as full backs. With Conor McManus returning from international duty and Andy Smith looking set to return to the starting eleven, it might be anticipated that Ainsworth will revert to the back three arrangement he has favoured this season.



Hopefully, top scorer Ronan Hale will be fit to start with attacking options expected to be bolstered further byTom Eaves’ availability, possibly joined by Bradley Dack and Will Goodwin.



Robbie McKenzie’s hamstring problem is expected to keep him out for a few weeks and unfortunately, Liam Gordon has experienced a minor slowdown in his recovery.



Crewe have concerns of their own. Club captain Mickey Demetriou suffered a further ankle setback during his return from a lower-leg injury and is expected to miss several more weeks. Jack Lankester, meanwhile, is nearing a return from a calf problem but Bell has stressed that he will not rush him back.

 


A look back down the line



Both of last season’s fixtures produced 1-0 home wins. Sam Gale scored the 89th minute winner at Priestfieldending Crewe’s perfect start to their league season. It was a memorable first goal for the Gills academy graduate now at Barnsley where he has made 11 League One appearances this season.



Substitute Adrien Thibaut scored the only goal following a set piece in the return at Gresty Road in Februarywith goalkeeper Ian Lawlor denying Ronan Hale and Sam Vokes with good saves.



Gillingham have not conceded to Crewe in their last three Priestfield meetings although have themselves only scored that one Gale goal. Crewe have not won at Priestfield since a 3-1 victory over Peter Taylor’s side featuring Dack in League One in March 2014.



That marked a fourth consecutive victory for The Railwaymen at Priestfield in a run that included their dramatic last-minute 4-3 win in March 2012.

 


Verdict



Crewe’s league position points to them being difficult opponents, but their recent form and away goalscoring record suggest they are far from invulnerable.



Ainsworth remains convinced that Gillingham will become a stronger proposition as injured players return. The challenge in the meantime is to remain in touch with the promotion contenders until they do. Three points against Crewe would be very welcome and hopefully restore some confidence that Priestfield can once again be a difficult place for visiting teams.


David Tickner writes regularly about Gillingham Football Club on Substack. You can read, follow or subscribe for free at Gills Journal | David Tickner | Substack.

 

Comments


AWAY TRAVEL BOOKINGS

Text Peter: 07930 443665

EMAIL US
SOCIAL MEDIA
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • X
bottom of page